You voted, and we listened. Chief photojournalist Mike Latta and his crew of "Professional Eaters" tallied up the votes and visited the second of the top three pizzerias.
1 of 21
Best Pizza Nominee: Bill Bobe's Pizzeria
With their palettes pleased from the precision thinness of Wise Pies Pizza, the group's next stop on their journey for the best pizza took them to Bilbo Bag...Bill Bobe's Pizzeria in Vincennes, Indiana.